5 ThredUp Finds I Can’t Wait to Style

What happens when secondhand shopping goes very, very right.

I used to scroll right past secondhand sites, convinced my style was lost somewhere beneath a sea of outdated office blazers. While I had heard of ThredUp, I hadn’t really given it a fair shot—until I came across a tip from Danielle Vermeer, ThredUp’s Head of Social Commerce, on how to search for today’s trends. That one trick flipped the script.

Now? My cart is stacked with romper dreams, retro heels, and the occasional poncho I didn’t even know I needed. I’ve been obsessed with cruising through their secondhand treasures (and by treasures, I do mean actual treasures). Most pieces are still en route—but that hasn’t stopped me from styling them in my head like I’m prepping for Fashion Week.

my latest ThredUp treasures

The Pieces I Found

Now for the fun part. Below are five standout pieces I recently scored on ThredUp—each one a little different, a little unexpected, and totally my style. I’ve included how I’m planning to wear them (and in some cases, how I already have).

Some have been styled. Some are still in the “dreaming up outfits in my head at midnight” phase. Either way, here’s a peek at what I found—and why I couldn’t pass them up.

If you haven’t used ThredUp yet and want to try it out, use this link for 45% off + free shipping on your first order.

1. The Farm Rio Shorts Romper

The Farm Rio Shorts Romper

The moment I saw this romper, I knew it was a yes. Farm Rio has become one of my go-to secondhand hunts—their pieces are bold, playful, and full of joy… but buying them brand-new can definitely add up. So anytime I find one pre-loved? Immediate heart-eyes.

This romper checks all the boxes: vibrant, unexpected, and bursting with color. It’s not the kind of piece that quietly joins your wardrobe—it makes an entrance. Rompers have always been one of my favorite things to wear (hello, one-and-done outfit magic), and I already know this one will be on heavy rotation all summer.

Whether I’m pairing it with heels, sneakers, or something weird and wonderful in between, this is the kind of find that makes secondhand shopping feel like a win every time.

💖 Look #1: Pink on Pink with Emerald Spark (Farm Rio Romper)

I scored both the romper and the heels from ThredUp recently. The Olga Berg Kimmie Hot Fix Top Handle was a lucky Poshmark find. I love how this look leans into the boldness—hot pink on hot pink with touches of emerald and gold. It’s playful, a little loud, and exactly how I like it.

💚 Look #2: Whimsy Meets Edge (Farm Rio Romper + Gia Couture Heels)

The green Gia Couture x Pernille Teisbaek heels were another ThredUp score, and they bring just enough edge to this otherwise whimsical look. Paired with a structured silver mini bag and bright accessories, this outfit feels like vacation—but elevated.

🫒 Look #3: A Walking Color Story (Farm Rio Romper)

I’m obsessed with the idea of layering different shades of green here. The bold chartreuse heels, the chunky dark green necklace, and the soft pop of fuchsia make it a walking color story. This one’s dying to be worn to a gallery opening or a weekend market.

---

2. Gia Couture x Pernille Teisbaek Heels

Gia Couture x Pernille Teisbaek Heels

When I saw these heels on ThredUp, it was a full-stop moment. The color? One of my forever favorites. The shape? Retro, sculptural, and surprisingly wearable. They’re not quiet shoes—they command the room. And when a piece starts generating outfit ideas before it even hits your doorstep, you know it’s a keeper.

Even better? They usually retail for $200–$400—and I snagged them for a steal. Honestly, I didn’t even blink.

🧡 Look #1: Structured Meets Sculptural (Gia Couture Heels + Tailored Vest)

This vest is what dreams are made of—another ThredUp find that feels like it was waiting for this exact shoe to come along. Together, they strike the perfect balance between soft tailoring and playful femininity.

💛 Look #2: Secondhand from Head to Toe (Gia Couture Heels)

This outfit is practically a walking ad for secondhand fashion. The top, the skirt, the heels, even the purse—every single piece was a lucky ThredUp find. Proof that you don’t need to shop new to serve a full look.

💗 Look #3: Chartreuse Statement Energy (Gia Couture Heels)

Chartreuse lovers, this one’s for us. I don’t shy away from color (clearly), and these heels give me the perfect excuse to lean all the way in. I’m already plotting this outfit’s debut—maybe a dinner date or an art walk?

---

3. Lilly Pulitzer Cocktail Dress

I mean… look at this Lilly dream I found on ThredUp.

I wasn’t even thinking about cocktail dresses—but the second I saw this one on ThredUp, I immediately thought of that scene from Sirens. You know the one: Devon slips into a Lilly Pulitzer dress and completely transforms. That moment now lives rent-free in my mind.

I mentioned it in one of my recent Everything I Wore This Week posts, but if you haven’t watched Sirens, consider this your sign. The casting? Incredible. The storyline? Hooked me instantly. I binged the entire thing in one night.

So when I spotted this Lilly dream secondhand, it felt like fashion fate.

one of my favorite scenes in Sirens

🥂 Look #1: Brunch, But Make It Palm Beach (Lilly Pulitzer Dress)

I’m already picturing this outfit at brunch—silver platform heels, a bow-top bag, and a pop of teal in the earrings. It feels classic but a little cheeky, like if Palm Beach got invited to bottomless mimosas.

🎨 Look #2: Gallery-Ready Florals (Lilly Pulitzer Dress + Denim Layers)

This one’s giving art walk energy. A denim jacket grounds the pastel florals, while bright pink heels and a sparkly purse bring the fun. It’s girly with a side of don’t underestimate me.

🐍 Look #3: Sweetness with Bite (Lilly Pulitzer Dress + Snakeskin Accents)

I wanted this look to clash. I wanted it to contrast. And it does exactly that. The snakeskin slides, sharp statement earrings, and a sleek black bag take the sweetness of the dress and give it a little bite. This one’s coming with me to the next vintage flea.

---

4. Chico’s Animal Print Skirt

The second I saw this leopard fringe moment, it practically shouted my name. It’s loud, it’s fun, it’s got movement—and most importantly, it refuses to be ignored. This is one of those pieces that turns getting dressed into a full creative exercise. I already knew I’d be styling it with bright heels and bold accessories, but the options? Truly endless.

So far, I’ve styled it three ways (with more on the horizon). I’m even toying with throwing on a blazer… or maybe going full contrast with a tube top. What do we think?

🟢 Look #1: Wild West But Make It Maximalist (Animal Print Skirt + Chartreuse Mules)

Chartreuse mules for the win. I love how the denim vest adds structure while the pop of green keeps things unexpected. Add in sculptural earrings and a woven mini bag, and it feels like a Western-inspired fever dream—in the best way.

💛 Look #2: Dramatic Errands Only (Animal Print Skirt + Yellow Crop Tee)

I can never resist a yellow moment. The cropped tee and raffia bag make it feel sporty and summery, while the earrings and mules bring in a little polish. This is what I’d wear for a casual dinner or even just to run errands…dramatically.

💖 Look #3: Fringe + Fuchsia Fever Dream (Animal Print Skirt + Pink Ruffles)

If the skirt gets its yellow moment, then pink was only fair. This one is full-on fun—ruffled fuchsia, metallic accessories, and the return of my favorite hot pink heels. It’s a look I’d pull out for a rooftop party or just because I’m in the mood to be seen.

---

5. Vince Camuto Mock-Neck Poncho

Vince Camuto Mock-Neck Poncho

I wasn’t searching for a poncho when I found this on ThredUp—but that’s the magic of secondhand treasure hunts. The outfit possibilities are unexpectedly good: I’m already imagining it with a romper, shiny leather pants, or even a sneaker moment with Sambas (more on that below).

Normally, I’d skip something like this—four dogs and delicate fabrics don’t exactly mix—but this one was too good of a deal to pass up. So I gave myself a hall pass… and I’m hoping my dogs will do the same.

✨ Look #1: Gallery Girl Energy (Poncho + Bike Short Romper)

I’m imagining this look for either a girls’ night or a First Friday event. The bike short romper keeps it modern and minimal while the poncho brings the drama. Add in statement earrings and silver platforms, and suddenly I’m that girl walking confidently into a gallery opening.

🤍 Look #2: Fall Layering Goals (Poncho + White Denim + Snakeskin Heels)

I’ll have to wait until fall hits to wear this one, but it’s at the top of my list. The white denim, bodysuit base, and snakeskin heels bring texture and polish, while the poncho floats perfectly over it all. A soft and stylish in-between-seasons look.

🖤 Look #3: Off-Duty Cool (Poncho + Slip Dress + Sambas)

These Sambas deserve their main character moment with this poncho. I love how this outfit balances sporty and sheer—like a cool-girl off-duty look with just enough intention. The black slip dress keeps things sleek, and the structured bag keeps it grounded.

---

What I Look for on ThredUp

My approach to ThredUp is part strategy, part serendipity. I always start by filtering by size, category, and style—it’s the easiest way to cut through the chaos and actually find pieces I’ll wear. Then, I zero in on the brands I stalk religiously: Farm Rio, Sézane, LoveShackFancy, Reformation, and Nasty Gal are always top of my list.

My general rule? If I can instantly imagine styling it three different ways, it’s going in the cart.

But one of the most fun parts? Discovering brands I’d never heard of before—like Doncaster Collection or Gia Couture x Pernille Teisbaek. It’s like thrifting meets fashion school—with extra credit for creativity.

Never tried ThredUp? Now’s the time. Use this link for 45% off and free shipping on your first order—aka your gateway to secondhand treasure hunting.

In addition to browsing ThredUp yourself, I highly recommend following Danielle Vermeer on Substack. She regularly shares incredible tips for navigating ThredUp like a pro—think keyword tricks, brand searches, and hidden gems. She’s singlehandedly made me better at secondhand shopping—like a personal shopper in Substack form. You can check out her Substack here.

Read More